Cost and schedule risk analysis
Running Monte Carlo simulation on the register and against your programme.
Both analyses are Monte Carlo simulations: the register is sampled many thousands of times, each run deciding independently which risks occur and how much they cost or delay, and the spread of outcomes is what the curves show. Nothing is fitted or smoothed; a curve is a count of runs.
Cost risk analysis (QCRA)
Open QCRA Analysis. The simulation runs in your browser from the current register, so there is nothing to submit and nothing to wait for beyond the run itself. Three controls sit above the results:
- Iterations: 10,000 by default, selectable from 1,000 to 25,000. More runs give a smoother curve at the tails; 10,000 is enough for a register of ordinary size.
- Seed: the starting point for the random numbers. The same seed on the same register gives the same result to the penny, which is what makes a figure in a report reproducible. Change it only to check that a conclusion does not depend on one particular draw.
- Confidence levels: P50, P65 and P80 by default. These are the percentiles reported in the table and marked on the curve.
Each risk is sampled from a triangular distribution across its minimum, most likely and maximum, and occurs in a run with its stated probability. The most likely value is weighted four to one in the expected-value figure, which is the standard PERT formula.
Who can do this
Reading the results
- Confidence curve (S-curve)
- Cumulative probability that the total risk cost is at or below a given figure. Read across from 80% to find the P80: the cost you have an 80% chance of not exceeding. A steep curve means a well-understood register; a long flat tail means a few large, uncertain risks.
- Histogram
- The same runs bucketed into slices (100 by default). Useful for spotting a register that is really two populations, for example a base case and a cluster of runs where one large risk occurred.
- Sensitivity (tornado)
- Each risk’s rank correlation with the portfolio total: how much of the movement in the total is explained by that risk. This is the list to take into a mitigation workshop, because the top few entries are where the money is.
- Per-risk table
- For every risk: its inputs, its expected value, its EMV, how often it occurred across the runs (which should be close to its stated probability) and its sensitivity.
The results are also rolled up by WBS code, which is what the WBS Explorer and the reports draw on.
The WBS explorer
WBS Explorer shows the work breakdown structure as a tree, with the simulated risk cost at every node: minimum, most likely, maximum, PERT expected value, EMV and the number of risks contributing. Expand a branch to trace exposure from the portfolio total down to a single package.
A node’s figure is the sum of the cost lines coded to it and to its children, so a risk whose cost lines have no WBS code contributes to the total but appears under no package. If the tree adds up to less than the register, that is where the difference is.
Schedule risk analysis (QSRA)
QSRA (Schedule) runs the register against your programme. The workflow has four parts, in this order:
- A schedule version. Import a programme file (see below), or create an empty version and enter activities by hand or by pasting CSV rows.
- Schedule health check. Deterministic logic checks on the imported programme: open ends, lags and leads, and duration validity. Nothing here blocks a run, but an open-ended activity cannot delay anything downstream, so fix what it finds before trusting the result.
- Duration uncertainty. Assign a heat-map template to activities individually, or select a WBS branch and bulk-assign one. This is the “how confident are we in the durations themselves” layer, separate from the risks.
- Risk-to-activity links. On each risk, tick the activities it would delay and set a delay estimate; or select several and bulk-assign one estimate. An optional AI panel proposes candidate activities from the risk’s description; nothing is written until you accept a suggestion.
The simulation then runs critical path analysis on every iteration (3,000 by default, up to 20,000) and reports:
- A pre- and post-mitigation confidence curve: the cumulative probability the programme finishes at or before a given date.
- Confidence levels from P5 to P100 as finish dates, gross against mitigated.
- Joint cost and schedule: a scatter of cost against finish date from the same iterations, and a target box where you type a cost and a date to see the probability that both are met together. This only appears once the register has enough linked risks for a joint view to mean anything.
Importing a programme
Programmes are imported through Documents, not through the QSRA page directly. Upload the file to the project’s document library, then choose Import as schedule on it. The activities and their logic are read in and a new schedule version is created and linked to the document.
Two formats are supported:
- Primavera P6 XER (
.xer) - Microsoft Project XML (
.xml, the MSPDI export)
Caution
.mpp) are not supported. Export to XML from within Project first. Asta Powerproject programmes should be exported to one of the two formats above.Files up to 25 MB can be parsed. A programme far larger than that is usually a sign the export contains more than the schedule, and the import will refuse it with a clear message rather than time out.
Still stuck?
Tell us what you were trying to do and what happened instead. A screenshot of the page helps more than a description of it.